Why Barbells?

A couple of weeks back I stumbled upon a truly great article on StartingStrength.com. Though generally I settle for sharing good articles on my Twitter feed and the Facebook page I think this one deserves special attention calling to it. Enter Michael Wolf….

Strength & Barbells: The Foundations of Fitness

If I had a dollar for every time a client or athlete has asked me why they have to do heavy squats and can’t they just do lunges instead, or the same question phrased slightly differently and with a different alternative exercise, I’d probably have enough money to equip the black iron gym I’ve been trying to open.  If I added to that the number of times I’ve seen similar questions asked in the forums, I could probably even afford the rent.

The issue of force production and its importance in life and athletics is dealt with at length in SS:BBT3, PPST2, and the SS Seminar. So why this article? Well, it seems that many people are still confused about it, despite the information available in those resources. For some, this may be due to laziness; actually read the book and attend the seminar, and it will all become clear.  For others, it may be a function of organization: the info is there to find, but scattered throughout the sources. When you quickly learn so much information on a subject with which you were previously only passingly acquainted, it can be difficult to assimilate all that new knowledge into a coherent package that you can pull out of your brain for later use. You’re convinced of the efficacy of strength and barbell training, but can’t quite organize a cogent response to the question “Why?”

What I’ll try to do here is give you the “Elevator Pitch,” to borrow the over-used phrase from the marketing industry, on force production and barbell training. I’ll attempt to answer the following two questions directly, in a briefer article form:

1) Why should training focus on strength/increasing force production?

2) Why is using barbells is the best way to accomplish this training goal?

Continue reading…

About the Author

Andy Morgan

I am the founder of RippedBody.com, this is my sincere effort to build the best nutrition and training guides on the internet. Some readers hire me to coach them, which I've been doing online, via email, for the last seven years. If you're interested in individualized, one-on-one nutrition and training coaching to help you crush your physique goals, let's start the conversation.

34 Comments

  1. Jared says:

    It seems the only advantage barbells have over dumbbells for upper body lifts is microloadability. But this easily addressed using magnetic microplates you can add to dumbbells or if using adjustable dumbbells you can buy 1.25 lb plates and 2.5 lb plates, thereby making microloadability equal to a barbell. Another argument is that you can’t train in the 1-5RM range on benching pressing and overhead pressing with dumbbells, but this is easily fixed by using unilateral dumbbell exercises (like one arm bench press and one arm OHP). The free arm aiding allows you to get the heavy dumbbell into the starting position without wasted energy, so you can lift 1-5RM loads. So for people who have an injury that’s aggravated by barbell lifts, unsuited biomenchanics for barbell lifts, or just don’t like barbell versions of bench press, OHP, and rows they can switch too dumbbells and, with the modifications I mentioned, get the same hypertrophy benefits as using a barbell. In fact for overhead pressing, the standing dumbbell overhead press elicits they highest activation of the deltoids so, given above modifications, it could actually be superior to the barbell. Lower body is where barbells give unique benefits compared to all other modalities but for the upper body I’m not convinced.

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      All valid points Jared. Thank you for taking the time to comment.

  2. Mike says:

    Hello Andy,
    I hit the local gym today for the 4th time in row and I asked the guy in charge there to help me learn the “Big 3” exercises. It’s my first time in gym and I can see that I am quite weak (and fat, 85 kg – 1.80m but soft :S ). The trainer there said that I am not ready for those exersices and that I could hurt myself if I am not strong already. He proposed a split training program with dumbells and other machines so that I train each muscle group once a week. I understand that this program is not for optimum muscle and strength gain nor for physique.
    I would like to ask for your opinion about that and if I should train in easier exercises before moving on to barbells and if I can achieve a result close to that of the big-3 doing mostly safer exercises.

    Thanks in advance

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Hi Mike. If you trust that they know what they are doing then go for it and don’t question it. They might be right and that might be your quickest way forward.
      If you don’t trust them though you need to find someone else, whether they are actually right or not, as you’ll just be second guessing them and ultimately undermining your own progress.

  3. Matt says:

    Andy,
    I think the bars I’ve seen here are the ones you’re talking about in shit gyms (this type, you can see the hex bolt in the end):
    https://www.bodymaker.jp/dc_SPORTS/sc_WeightTraining/d/BSOS/

    I’ve heard that the pin either comes loose or seizes up over time, or just plain snaps when you drop it. Plus these cheap bars look likely to bend and stay bent. Guess I’ll be saving up to have a decent quality bar shipped over from the US!

    BTW, this is quite a good article on olympic bar types:
    https://www.garage-gyms.com/olympic-barbell-review-shopping-guide/

    Thanks,
    Matt.

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Let me ask down the gym today for you where they buy their bars from.

  4. Matt says:

    Andy,
    What are your thoughts on the different types of Olympic bars available? I’m training with a basic 28mm type bar at the moment, but am thinking about getting an Olympic bar and plates one day. Most bars I’ve seen here in Japan have the hex bolt (pin) type sleeve, as opposed to the snap ring type seen on better quality bars. I’ve read it’s best to steer clear of pin sleeve bars completely for various reasons, and am thinking of ordering a bar from Rogue in the States if it means having something that’ll last a lifetime. Do you have any experience of the two types of sleeves?
    Thanks,
    Matt.

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      I’m not that familiar with all the different barbells and terminology, nor the ones you’re talking about to be honest.

      From my experience in Japan it tends to be that, if you train at a good gym, they’re one of two types – where only the knurling differs. Then if you are at an excellent gym, you have bars of different stiffnesses (some will have more bend and snap). Then you get the bars in shit gyms that have the cheap stuff marketed to people building a home gym, where the bars are often under 20kg/45lbs and don’t have the freely rotating ends to take the inertia out (sorry not sure of the correct term), which must have caused many people to hilariously backwards flip over the years when power cleaning or otherwise.

  5. William Pike says:

    Hi Andy,

    Followed the link from the bodyweight question to this page, wondering if you’ve revisited body-weight for a full blog post.
    I looked at Convict Conditioning progression tables for body-weight, and am doing that for a month while I think about going back to RPT or 5×5 (been doing the former for half a year) I have to say, it’s pretty gnarly work.. if you get to the mastery levels, and then add weight, you’d be very strong and athletic I’m sure (1 arm handstand push-up?)

    Anyway, just hoping you’d write a post on the feasibility of bodyweight workouts as a replacement or substitution for barbell workouts.

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Hi William, thanks for the question:
      “Followed the link from the bodyweight question to this page, wondering if you’ve revisited body-weight for a full blog post.”
      – I haven’t and I probably won’t as achieving consistent overload for an extended period with body weight alone is difficult, and honestly as it’s not my field of expertise it’s better to let someone else do it.

  6. tuna says:

    Completely converted fully to only barbells and dumbbells. Completely different progress. My only wish is I did it sooner.

    For anyone else debating, I say go for it if you’re healthy! The progress on your body will be more significant.

  7. Susan says:

    Andy what is your take on training the Big Three on the Smith machine. The gym I am currently at does not offer a free barbell rack more than 60 lbs. My biggest concern would be the squats on the smith machine. Obviously there’s a modificaton with the smith machine, having to lean backward vs leaning forward in the squat. Will this compromise or stall my results? Also, would you advise various forms of the Big Three (ex. front squat vs reg squat, barbell press vs incline barbell press) when training or is that unnecessary?

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Covered in the FAQ Susan.

  8. Tuna says:

    Hey Andy!

    Any recommendations when it comes to grip strength on higher weight dumbbells? I’m having trouble gripping 75lbs with my left hand as it wants to give out much sooner than my right hand. I figure maybe holding the weight in my hand for as long as possible to build grip strength but wanted to run by you first. Thank you Andy!

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Probably best to wait for your grip to develop naturally and not force it for connective tissue health.

  9. Pedro says:

    Hi Andy, big fan of your website here. I’ve been following Leangains for 4 months and I dropped from around 20% bf to 12% with tons of muscle gain. However, my max weights have decreased by 10% in the last month, especially bench press and overhead press. I guess you can’t lose that much fat without losing some strength in the process.
    My question is: Martin says that you can interchange Leg Presses and Squats. What are your thoughts on this?
    Cheers

    1. Andy Morgan says:

      Squats are not mandatory, and leg presses can be used by people yes. They are not a direct swap though because of the different musculature worked.

Questions welcomed. (Over 16,000 answered)

For the sake of other readers, please:
  • Keep questions on topic,
  • Write clearly, concisely, and click reply when responding,
  • Don't post diet calculations or full training plans asking me to critique them as it depends too heavily on context.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.